Week 9; Post 2
Before I begin my exploration into the new ISP filtering system of Australia, This, I found interesting;
What is Barak Obama up to today? Can you send him a message about the importance of freedom on the internet?
Amazingly, after finding the Whitehouse website, It is possible to contact the whitehouse directly. According to the Site <http://www.whitehouse.gov/> Yesterday President Obama met with World Leaders at the UN general Assembly. Contacting the Whitehouse directly is pretty simple. Simply fill in some of your details and you have added your thoughts to the government.
What are the Australian Government's plans to censor the internet (the so-called "Clean Feed")?
ISP Filtering is the governments attempt at blocking certain content for viewing on the internet. According to the governments site "The government has announced that it will introduce legislative amendments to require all ISPs in Australia to use ISP-level filtering to block overseas hosted Refused Classification (RC) material on the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) RC Content list." (Internet Service Provider (ISP) Filtering 2011) According to the government, Refused Classification (RC) includes, but is not limited to child sexual abuse imagery, bestiality, sexual violence, detailed instruction in crime, violence or drug use and/or material that advocates the doing of a terrorist act.
Due to the overwhelming fact that the ISP Filtering is based soley on the results of the classification of certain sites, the minister of broadband in Australia is undertaking the task of reviewing the criteria. Until that time, the filtering system will not be put into place. However, After looking through other, more opinional sites throughout the internet, it is evident that the ISP system is not in the good books for a lot of people. Whirlpool provided a list as to why; "Blacklisted sites are kept secret from the Australian public; Any blacklist would need to be distributed to all ISPs in Australia, and will provide anyone a concentrated list of the 'worst of the worst' web pages when leaked; It introduces delay and declined performance in internet traffic; It will increase the cost of broadband; Filtering products incorrectly block legitimate traffic" (Clean Feed, 2011) to name a few. Another problem in the eyes of majority of the Australian public concerned with the ISP filtering system, is what options will website owners have if they feel that there site was inappropriately place on the RC list. To this the government simply, and pathetically, writes "The Minister for Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy announced on 9 July 2010 a comprehensive suite of transparency and accountability measures that will accompany the introduction of ISP filtering." (ISP Filtering - frequently asked questions, 2011) Seemingly, at the end of the day, the argument, irrespective of technological or legal reasons comes down to this "Australia is supposed to be a liberal democracy where adults have the freedom to say and read what they want, not just what the Government decides is 'appropriate' for them." (Taylor, 2008) The new system shows strong traits of a dictatorship style government, with Electronic Frontiers Australia even foregrounding the similarities between the new system, and previously implemented filtering systems in China, North Korea and Burma. Overall, this debate, as is shown by the date on the document for the Electronic Frontiers Australia page, has been continued for years. How will the system ultimately be put into place? who knows, However from what I can see, the government better watch their step, because one wrong move could spell the end of the minister of broad bands career.
Due to the overwhelming fact that the ISP Filtering is based soley on the results of the classification of certain sites, the minister of broadband in Australia is undertaking the task of reviewing the criteria. Until that time, the filtering system will not be put into place. However, After looking through other, more opinional sites throughout the internet, it is evident that the ISP system is not in the good books for a lot of people. Whirlpool provided a list as to why; "Blacklisted sites are kept secret from the Australian public; Any blacklist would need to be distributed to all ISPs in Australia, and will provide anyone a concentrated list of the 'worst of the worst' web pages when leaked; It introduces delay and declined performance in internet traffic; It will increase the cost of broadband; Filtering products incorrectly block legitimate traffic" (Clean Feed, 2011) to name a few. Another problem in the eyes of majority of the Australian public concerned with the ISP filtering system, is what options will website owners have if they feel that there site was inappropriately place on the RC list. To this the government simply, and pathetically, writes "The Minister for Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy announced on 9 July 2010 a comprehensive suite of transparency and accountability measures that will accompany the introduction of ISP filtering." (ISP Filtering - frequently asked questions, 2011) Seemingly, at the end of the day, the argument, irrespective of technological or legal reasons comes down to this "Australia is supposed to be a liberal democracy where adults have the freedom to say and read what they want, not just what the Government decides is 'appropriate' for them." (Taylor, 2008) The new system shows strong traits of a dictatorship style government, with Electronic Frontiers Australia even foregrounding the similarities between the new system, and previously implemented filtering systems in China, North Korea and Burma. Overall, this debate, as is shown by the date on the document for the Electronic Frontiers Australia page, has been continued for years. How will the system ultimately be put into place? who knows, However from what I can see, the government better watch their step, because one wrong move could spell the end of the minister of broad bands career.
Internet Service Provider (ISP) Filtering, 2011, viewed 21 September 2011, <http://www.dbcde.gov.au/funding_and_programs/cybersafety_plan/internet_service_provider_isp_filtering>
Clean Feed, 2011, viewed 21 September 2011, <http://whirlpool.net.au/wiki/cleanfeed>
ISP Filtering frequently Asked questions, 2011, viewed 21 September 2011, <http://www.dbcde.gov.au/funding_and_programs/cybersafety_plan/internet_service_provider_isp_filtering/isp_filtering_live_pilot/isp_filtering_-_frequently_asked_questions#8.0>
Taylor, G 2008, Media release - EFA Attaks Clean-Feed Proposal, viewed 21 September 2011, <http://www.efa.org.au/2008/01/02/media-release-efa-attacks-clean-feed-proposal/>